While in Aruba, I heard many stories about her death and locals and tourist’s opinions on what happened. I also heard a few stories from self-proclaimed ghost hunters and psychics.
One man claimed to have captured an EVP that said, “Please, help me.” He swears the faint female voice belonged to Natalie Holloway and he believes the area where he captured this is where she was before she passed away.
Another person who claimed to be a psychic said that she has seen Holloway’s apparition walking along the side of the road soaking wet and appears to be lost and scared. She stated that many people who have seen her stop to see if she needs help or a ride and she vanishes as soon as they stop.
My Historic Haunts Investigations team did not encounter her while we were there but we all hope her and her family find peace.